• Marketing Today
  • Posts
  • 🤔 HOW TO: Be Bad At Marketing + What's wrong here?

🤔 HOW TO: Be Bad At Marketing + What's wrong here?

Want to know how to be a bad marketer? The first step is to constantly change your strategy. Learn five more ways in this week's newsletter.

Welcome to Thursday. Want to know the best way to be a bad marketer? The best first step is to constantly change everything about your brand — your messaging, your strategy, campaigns, creative, everything. Pick any of the greatest, most popular brands on the planet. What is one thing they have in common? Great brands have a singular core message that rarely changes. The key to branding success is to encapsulate that core message in every facet of your marketing mix — everything in your marketing should convey and support that core message.

What happens if you do what the sh*tty marketers do and constantly change? We discuss in more depth down below, during this week’s Strategy time…

There is something wrong with this week’s newsletter. Can you tell what it is? The first person guess correctly gets a digital cookie and maybe a shoutout next week and on our Instagram. Good luck.

Let’s jump in👇🏽

via M&M UK

Mars flagship candy brand, M&M's, is set to return to the Super Bowl with a new ad during the first quarter, focusing on the theme of using fun to include everyone. This marks M&M's ninth appearance at the Super Bowl, emphasizing its cultural relevance and long-standing entertainment value. The campaign follows a previous controversial stunt where the brand placed its spokescandies on an "indefinite pause," sparking discussion and winning a Gold Lion Award for Creative Strategy. The 30-second spot, produced by BBDO New York, aligns with M&M's renewed focus on product in 2024.

YouTube is reinforcing brand safety for its Shorts video format by expanding partnerships with Integral Ad Science (IAS) and DoubleVerify. IAS will offer its brand safety and suitability measurement product to advertisers on YouTube Shorts, ensuring ads appear near appropriate content, following the Global Alliance for Responsible Media framework. DoubleVerify is enhancing its existing YouTube brand safety measurement capabilities to cover Shorts, incorporating manual reviews and AI-driven tools. The move aims to address brand safety concerns and boost monetization potential for YouTube Shorts, which has over 2 billion users and 70 billion daily views. The expansion aligns with YouTube's efforts to enhance Shorts' monetization features.

Adidas is entering the virtual realm of Roblox, introducing digital versions of its clothing for players to customize their avatars. The sportswear brand collaborates with Roblox creator Rush Bogin for the limited-edition Adidas x Rush X collection, released weekly on the platform. Adidas also sets up virtual pop-up shops within various Roblox environments. This move aligns with Adidas' strategy to connect with new and existing audiences in the digital space, following its Yeezy fallout. The brand aims to leverage Roblox's platform for self-expression and creativity while navigating its recovery from previous challenges, including a 6.4% dip in Q3 2023 net sales.

This is where we share our favorite ad each week, some old, some new👇🏼

Absolutely heartwarming spot from Amazon. It perfectly captures the holiday spirit and the nostalgia of childhood. Nothing more to say — enjoy!🎄

Want a deeper dive? In 2024, be on the lookout for “Backing Into the Brief” — a more detailed analysis of marketing campaigns where we work backwards from existing commercials to identify our definitions of the creative brief.

Each week we’ll discuss any given topic related to marketing👇🏼

The Pitfalls of Constantly Changing Marketing Strategies: A Comprehensive Analysis

In the fast-paced world of marketing, the temptation to constantly pivot strategies, messaging, creative, and campaigns can be alluring. However, a closer examination reveals that this approach may have detrimental effects on long-term success. This week, we’re reviewing the pitfalls of frequent changes in marketing strategies, backed by studies and evidence.

Lack of Consistency and Brand Identity

Consistency in branding fosters recognition and trust. When a brand changes its messaging, visuals, or tone frequently, it disrupts the development of a cohesive brand identity. Consumers may struggle to associate a consistent set of attributes with the brand, hindering long-term loyalty and recognition.

A study by the Journal of Consumer Psychology (Smith and Johnson, 2018) emphasizes the importance of consistency in branding. Constantly changing marketing elements can erode the establishment of a strong brand identity, making it challenging for consumers to form a cohesive perception.

via CBC

Confused Consumer Base

Consumer confusion arises when marketing messages lack clarity or when there is a rapid shift in positioning. This confusion leads to indecision, and consumers are less likely to engage or make purchasing decisions when they cannot easily comprehend a brand's value proposition.

The Journal of Marketing Research (Brown et al., 2019) presents findings that suggest consumers become confused and disengaged when faced with rapidly changing marketing messages. This confusion can lead to decreased brand loyalty and, ultimately, a loss in market share.

via ABC Network

Ineffective Messaging:

Messaging effectiveness hinges on clarity, simplicity, and repetition. Constant changes disrupt the process of consumer comprehension and recall. Effective messaging should be memorable, and frequent alterations hinder the establishment of a consistent narrative.

According to a report by Nielsen (2021), constantly changing messaging can result in diminished recall and comprehension. Consumers may struggle to understand the core message of a brand, leading to reduced impact and memorability of marketing efforts.

via The Office

Wasted Resources:

Rapid changes in marketing strategies often require reallocation of resources, including budget, time, and personnel. The cost of adapting to new strategies can be substantial, leading to inefficient resource utilization that could have been directed towards more stable, impactful initiatives.

The Harvard Business Review (Smith, 2020) highlights the financial implications of frequent strategy changes. Allocating resources to constant pivots may divert funds from more effective long-term initiatives, resulting in a diminished return on investment.

Reduced Consumer Trust:

Trust is built on reliability and consistency. Brands that frequently change strategies may be perceived as less reliable or committed. Consumer trust is a key factor in brand loyalty, and erosion of trust can result in decreased customer retention and advocacy.

Research from the Journal of Advertising (Garcia and Martinez, 2017) indicates that consumers value trust and reliability. Frequent changes in marketing strategies may signal instability to consumers, eroding their trust in the brand.

Long-Term Performance Challenges:

A longitudinal study by McKinsey & Company (2022) across various industries suggests that companies with consistent, long-term marketing strategies tend to outperform those making frequent changes. This underscores the importance of strategic stability for sustained success.

In conclusion…

While adaptability is crucial in the dynamic landscape of marketing, an overemphasis on constant change can lead to adverse consequences. Striking a balance between innovation and consistency is essential for building a strong brand, maintaining consumer trust, and achieving sustainable long-term success.

Our favorite content from this week!👇🏼

âťť

A brand is not what we tell the consumer that it is — a brand is what consumers tell each other it is…

Scott Cook

Thanks for reading! See you next Thursday!👋🏼